Overcompensating Is the Fix I Didn't Know I Needed

This R-rated college series from Benito Skinner might just be the most unexpected debut of 2025. Benny's finally off to college, free from his heteronormative life back home—but he's still confused as ever. “Is it time to come out? Am I safe? Could I maybe still be straight?” Though the story begins with Benny, Overcompensating quickly expands into the lives of the other characters on campus with him, tackling LGBTQ+ themes without overshadowing its superior cast.

Overcompensating isn't about the plot—it's about the characters, and the ensemble is electric. Every actor feels like they were born to play their role (even the ones playing themselves). I can't pick a standout because I fear they all gave show-stopping performances. Everyone is overcompensating for something, and the title makes more sense as we learn about each person. These characters have multiple versions of themselves, often putting on a mask and trying to impress others in places they're not even sure they want to be. It's awkward to watch, but only because we've been exactly there.

The screenwriting  is fully immersed in internet culture, as if each episode was written the day they filmed. The jokes are sharp, the story is chaotic, and the energy is cathartic. Simultaneously,  the show still manages to offer each character their own individual arc. It's over the top and down to earth all at once. Watching it feels like you're a student on Yates’ campus, emerging in the mess as it all unfolds. 

My highlight of the season is easily episode 5. Peak television. I've thought about it at least seven times a day since watching it. Every storyline colliding, the shots, the surprises, and hearing "Claws" by Charli XCX?? My Roman Empire.

In an era full of reboots and overdone high school dramas Overcompensating fills a gap I don't think others even knew was there. It dives headfirst into what it's like to navigate life on your own–when so many young adults feel lonelier and more disconnected than ever before.

Overcompensating is a show for the underdogs and the girls who get it. It's self-aware, honest, and brilliant.

Some might say it's too early to tell—but this is my show of the year. 5/5. Amazon, on behalf of the people, I beg you to renew this for a second season.

Curious about what Noah is into? Get real-time updates at shelf.im/noah